5 Reasons Why Shoaib Malik’s Participation in PSL 2025 is Stirring Controversy

Controversial Comeback: Shoaib Malik’s PSL 2025 Appearance

At 43, Shoaib Malik’s return to the Pakistan Super League (PSL) as a player for Quetta Gladiators has sparked a wave of controversy. Once a celebrated captain of Pakistan, Malik is being criticized for continuing to play at an age when many are retired or mentoring.

1. Conflict of Interest Concerns

Last year, Malik took on a mentorship role with the domestic Pakistan side, Stallions, for the Champions One-Day Cup. His dual role has raised concerns about potential conflicts of interest, a recurring issue in Pakistan cricket.

2. Calls for Limitations from Former Teammates

Mohammad Yousuf, a former teammate, has publicly expressed his reservations. He believes that the Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) should set clear boundaries on player eligibility to prevent conflicts and maintain the integrity of the sport.

3. Mixed Reactions from Cricket Legends

While some like Shahid Afridi support Malik’s right to play indefinitely, they also emphasize the importance of giving opportunities to younger talent. Afridi suggests that Malik should selectively participate in matches, allowing emerging players to showcase their skills.

4. Underwhelming Performance Stats

Malik’s performance in the current PSL season has been underwhelming. He has managed only 14 runs in two matches and has failed to take any wickets, fueling further debate over his place in the team.

5. The Future of PSL Player Eligibility

The ongoing discussion around Shoaib Malik’s participation could prompt the PCB to rethink its policies on player age and roles within teams, ensuring that the league remains a platform for both experienced and upcoming players.

The evolving narrative around Malik’s role in PSL 2025 continues to garner attention and could lead to significant changes in how player eligibility and roles are viewed in the future.