Unpacking the Controversy: Analyzing Ishan Kishan’s Questionable Dismissal in IPL 2025

Introduction

” alt=”Ishan Kishan and Hardik Pandya in action during IPL 2025″>

In a stunning moment during the IPL 2025, Ishan Kishan’s unexpected dismissal during the Sunrisers Hyderabad versus Mumbai Indians match ignited a debate across the cricketing world. The incident, which unfolded in the third over, involved a missed leg-side shot by Kishan, leading to an unusual series of events.

The Incident Explained

With the match tension running high, Ishan Kishan attempted to hit a ball from Deepak Chahar but missed, allowing the wicket-keeper, Ryan Rickelton, to gather the ball. Surprisingly, Kishan began walking towards the dugout without any appeal from the fielding side. The umpire, Vinod Seshan, initially moved to signal a wide but abruptly changed his decision to out as Kishan walked off the pitch. Replay footage later confirmed that the ball had not touched the bat.

MCC Law 31.7 on Player Dismissal

Under the MCC’s Law 31.7, an interesting scenario unfolds with Kishan’s dismissal:

  • The law states that if a batter is not out but leaves the crease under the misconception of being dismissed, the umpire should intervene, signal a dead ball, and recall the batter unless it is the final wicket or the umpires are leaving the field.
  • In Kishan’s scenario, the umpire chose not to intervene, possibly influenced by Kishan’s own assumption and body language that he was out.

The Aftermath and Game Outcome

Despite the controversy, Mumbai Indians showcased a strong game, led by Rohit Sharma, who notched up a robust half-century, contributing significantly to the team’s victory:

  • Rohit Sharma continued his excellent form, scoring 70 runs off 46 balls.
  • Together with Suryakumar Yadav, who remained not out at 40, they secured a resounding seven-wicket win over the Sunrisers Hyderabad.
  • The victory was also supported by an impressive bowling stint from Deepak Chahar and Trent Boult, who devastated the early batting lineup of the Sunrisers Hyderabad.

Conclusion

The Ishan Kishan dismissal incident has sparked discussions about the nuances of cricket rules and the responsibilities of umpires during such unclear circumstances. As it stands, the controversy remains a talking point for cricket analysts and enthusiasts alike.

Related: 5 Key Takeaways from Mumbai Indians’ Fourth Consecutive IPL Victory Under Hardik Pandya

Last Updated: April 24, 2025

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *